Winning Affection

Everyone has been talking about the new Grand Theft Auto game and despite the glowing praise, I’ve got some serious skepticism. I’ve never been a fan of the series. The violence and glorification of crime is enough of a turn off to me that I really don’t care about the mechanics or the playability. I played the first version of the game when it came out and it looked like racing RC cars around a flat map. It seemed like a pretty standard game trying to market itself with an edgy premise and one that couldn’t be delivered effectively with the technology that existed at the time. 

It’s possible the series is maturing, though, if the reviews are any indication. Jason Sheehan writes for NPR about the changes. 

And what’s remarkable about the whole bloody delight is that it remains, until its final operatic moments, so surprisingly grounded. This is a somewhat more mature GTA than its predecessors, trading aliens, cannibal cultists and whacked-out drug trips for wellness influencers, local politics and the music industry. Jason and Lucia’s relationship is the superstructure around which the entire narrative is built, and it’s a dynamic thing that must be maintained in a dozen little ways — making coffee in the morning, opening doors for each other, date nights (even if that means robbing a jewelry store together), or holding hands as you walk toward yet another betrayal by someone you thought you could trust. You can switch freely between them, or just call the other one to come drive the getaway car. Let their relationship dwindle and the narrative shifts, flattens.

The element of romance, of realistic self-sacrificial and challenging love for another person seems out-of-place in this series. It’s welcome nonetheless. At least, I welcome it as a positive element in a game dynasty mostly devoid of them. Not everyone shares the attitude, though. 

Wired Magazine‘s Miles Klee writes about the backlash from a certain segment of male gamers. It’s hard to know how widespread the phenomenon is (after all, journos have to write about something controversial), but Klee does provide examples of influencers who are disgusted at the thought of having to try to win a woman’s affection in a game that is usually known for catering to their violent impulses.

What’s truly remarkable, though, is that adult men who grew up indulging their most selfish and sociopathic instincts in the older GTA games have had their nostalgia for those escapades cleverly complicated with real-life problems. They can still steal cars, sell drugs, and rise through the ranks of a seedy underworld. That will always be the appeal of the series, which is now asking eternally aggrieved culture warriors to consider a vital question: What if you didn’t have to do it alone?

I’m not going to pretend that I’ll ever play the game or comprehend enough about it to be able to endorse its content. I do think that more men need to understand what it means to give part of yourself to someone in pursuit of a life together.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *